---
title: "An Ongoing Legal Battle Could Determine the Future of AI Used in Art - Get a Free Network Security Consultation in South Florida"
description: "An artist who created art with AI is struggling to obtain copyright for his work. What’s his argument?"
url: "https://www.l7solutions.com/blog/an-ongoing-legal-battle-could-determine-the-future-of-ai-used-in-art"
date: "2026-06-19T22:24:13+00:00"
language: "en-GB"
---
## Get a Free Network Security Consultation in South Florida
Get a free network security consultation today from L7 Solutions. We are your partner for managed services & IT support in South Florida and beyond. Call today.
[ Categories ](https://www.l7solutions.com/blog/categories "Categories")
[ Tags ](https://www.l7solutions.com/blog/tags "Tags")
[ Categories: All Categories ](https://www.l7solutions.com/javascript:void(0); "Categories")
Search...Suggested keywords
[ x ](https://www.l7solutions.com/javascript:void(0);)
# An Ongoing Legal Battle Could Determine the Future of AI Used in Art
[LSeven Solutions Blog](https://www.l7solutions.com/blog/categories/blog) [Miscellaneous](https://www.l7solutions.com/blog/categories/miscellaneous)
[LSeven Solutions Admin](https://www.l7solutions.com/blog/blogger/l7-admin)
Friday, 25 October 2024
[ 0 Comments ](https://www.l7solutions.com/blog/an-ongoing-legal-battle-could-determine-the-future-of-ai-used-in-art#comments)
[  ](//www.l7solutions.com/images/easyblog_shared/October_2024/10-25-24/AICopyright_568714025_400.jpg "An Ongoing Legal Battle Could Determine the Future of AI Used in Art")
You might remember the buzz when Josh Allen, a digital artist, won first place at the 2022 Colorado State Fair for his digital artwork called "Théâtre D'opéra Spatial." The catch? He created the image using AI. Now, he’s in a fight with the Copyright Office to prove that his work deserves copyright protection.
## Copyright Office Denies Copyright
In 2023, Allen tried to get a copyright for his winning piece, but the Copyright Office said no—twice. They argued that Allen didn’t have enough control over the final image because he used an AI tool to create it. The Office explained that since Allen didn’t directly control how the AI responded to his instructions (or “prompts”), the image wasn’t fully his creation.
## Allen Fights Back
Allen is challenging the decision, saying the Copyright Office was influenced by all the media attention his work got. He argues that the Office shouldn’t judge whether art is made by AI or by humans because it’s not always easy to tell. Allen thinks this sets a bad example for how AI-generated art is treated, especially as technology gets better.
He’s now going to court to explain that, while the AI helped create the image, he spent over 100 hours carefully crafting over 600 prompts to guide the AI in making the exact image he had in his head—women in Victorian dresses with space helmets, performing opera on stage. Allen believes that his time, effort, and direction make him the true creator of the artwork.
## The Copyright Office’s Take
The Copyright Office agrees that Allen’s prompts are original and can be protected. However, they say the final image generated by the AI cannot be copyrighted because Allen didn’t create it entirely by hand. They also mentioned that if Allen had made more edits to the image, like adding a filter, he could’ve registered his copyright without any issues.
## What’s Next?
It’s unclear how this case will end, but it highlights how tricky it can be to figure out who owns AI-generated content. Allen’s battle with the Copyright Office has been going on for a while, and it may take even longer to get a final decision.
So, what do you think? Should artists be able to copyright works made with AI, or does the fact that a machine did most of the work change things?
[ ](https://www.l7solutions.com/javascript:void(0);) [ ](https://www.l7solutions.com/javascript:void(0);) [ ](https://www.l7solutions.com/javascript:void(0);)
Tags:
[Current Events](https://www.l7solutions.com/blog/tags/current-events) [Innovation](https://www.l7solutions.com/blog/tags/innovation) [AI](https://www.l7solutions.com/blog/tags/ai)
[ Data Backups are Critical for Modern Businesses ](https://www.l7solutions.com/blog/data-backups-are-critical-for-modern-businesses)
[ These IT Services Help You Compete with the Big Gu... ](https://www.l7solutions.com/blog/these-it-services-help-you-compete-with-the-big-guys)
About the author
[  ](https://www.l7solutions.com/blog/blogger/l7-admin)
[LSeven Solutions Admin](https://www.l7solutions.com/blog/blogger/l7-admin)
[ ](https://www.l7solutions.com/javascript:void(0); "Subscribe to updates from author") [ ](https://www.l7solutions.com/javascript:void(0);) [ ](https://www.l7solutions.com/blog/blogger/l7-admin)
Welcome to LSeven's Blog! Here we will share useful tips and tricks for Computers and Information on Our IT Services!
Author's recent posts
[More posts from author](https://www.l7solutions.com/blog/blogger/l7-admin)
[ Tuesday, 30 June 2026 Stop Managing Metal, Start Managing People: A Guide to Hybrid IT ](https://www.l7solutions.com/blog/stop-managing-metal-start-managing-people-a-guide-to-hybrid-it)
[ Saturday, 27 June 2026 Free AI is Not Free: Why Public Tools Are a Security Risk ](https://www.l7solutions.com/blog/free-ai-is-not-free-why-public-tools-are-a-security-risk)
[ Thursday, 25 June 2026 Phishing is Getting Sophisticated: The New Threats Businesses Face ](https://www.l7solutions.com/blog/phishing-is-getting-sophisticated-the-new-threats-businesses-face)
Comments
No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
**** Already Registered? [Login Here](https://www.l7solutions.com/component/users/login?return=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cubDdzb2x1dGlvbnMuY29tL2Jsb2cvYW4tb25nb2luZy1sZWdhbC1iYXR0bGUtY291bGQtZGV0ZXJtaW5lLXRoZS1mdXR1cmUtb2YtYWktdXNlZC1pbi1hcnQ=&Itemid=101)
Friday, 19 June 2026
Subscribe to the blog (Please fill in your email address to subscribe to updates from this post.)
**Captcha Image**
## Schema
```json
{
"@context": "https://schema.org",
"@type": "BreadcrumbList",
"itemListElement": [
{
"@type": "ListItem",
"position": 1,
"name": "Home",
"item": "https://www.l7solutions.com"
},
{
"@type": "ListItem",
"position": 2,
"name": "Blog",
"item": "https://www.l7solutions.com/blog"
},
{
"@type": "ListItem",
"position": 3,
"name": "LSeven Solutions Admin",
"item": "https://www.l7solutions.com/blog/blogger/l7-admin"
},
{
"@type": "ListItem",
"position": 4,
"name": "An Ongoing Legal Battle Could Determine the Future of AI Used in Art",
"item": "https://www.l7solutions.com/blog/an-ongoing-legal-battle-could-determine-the-future-of-ai-used-in-art"
}
]
}
```